General Discussion

General DiscussionDoes dotabuff community think Smash deserves a second chance?

Does dotabuff community think Smash deserves a second chance? in General Discussion
Dogwater

    He posted something on reddit

    https://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/7iv3ne/open_letter_to_valve_dota2_community_about/?utm_source=amp&utm_medium=comment_list

    If any of you guys know about the details. Lets see what dotabuff community thinks about issues like morals and redemption.

    Basically: tl;dr
    He fixed some matches, life was hard for them, hes sorry and wants to be forgiven.

    ywn

      yes

      Shou

        probably not
        solo is the only exception cuz it was shady shit before a rule was properly organized, and its still biting his ass
        letting more people go free from this shit is not a good message to send imo

        kAtala

          Someone says that life is hard. Someone have been in the same situation as him, and they did not 322. I guess, it's just because they have no chance to 322. Life is really hard. It is all about the mindset of people. But, at the time Dota Community are getting smaller, Valve should do the right thing and give him another chance. In my opinion.

          კომენტარი შეიცვალა
          Bad Intentions

            Hey man, everybody deserves a second chance..

            BSJ. LGD

              first offence perma bans are stupid imo.

              Seoulmate

                probably

                TripleSteal-

                  no
                  he even tries to blame his ex teammates

                  Nz Yhwach

                    yes, he made a mistake in the past, but i've think he learned the lesson

                    pingwin

                      Also he sold boosting services

                      Songforged

                        Not at all. He damaged the integrity of the dota scene and of the community, which a lot of people worked so hard to build up. Matchfixing is such a shameful thing to do. It completely ruins e-sports. The fact that he was going through hard times is a terrible excuse. If you're going through hard times, you get a day job, not join an e-sport team and fix a match. This guy also sold boosting services. He willingly ruined the game of tons of people for money.

                        Those of you who say that he should get a second chance have no clue. Where is the competitiveness if a team willingly throws the game for money. What kind of a shitfest would the game become if match-fixers were given a second chance?

                        კომენტარი შეიცვალა
                        Cursed

                          Probably not, south american doto is shady af.

                          Cheap Laugh Guy

                            I don't even care about Smash FREE MA BOI DDZ!!!!!!!!!!!

                            Jacked

                              Harsh penalties are warranted. Match fixing can really ruin the ecosystem.

                              megs

                                He serves well as an example of what happens when you match fix.

                                UnSure

                                  I personally don't think he does because he knew the rules. After the whole 322 think everyone knew the rules.

                                  I will say that the issue isn't as simple as just giving him a 2nd chance.
                                  It affects other players and games as well. Its sets a precedent.

                                  კომენტარი შეიცვალა
                                  Rocket

                                    No. Incredibly hard to spot cheats in esports. It is crucial that the punishments are harsh and a deterrent.

                                    Shou

                                      Why TF shud he get a second chance?
                                      U don't think other pros have experienced the same harsh living as him?
                                      SunBhie made a good tweet abt it

                                      BASIIIIIIIIC

                                        I rape 1 person because life is hard and i cant have a gf. Can i have i second chance?

                                        If hes given second chance all others like ddz will also ask for a second chance. Why there are rules in the first place?

                                        There life gone hard because they invested most if not all of there time and talent in a video game where only the top few are rewarded. And the only place where they could be rewarded by playing this game is the one they did not respect.

                                        me, government hooker

                                          who is this guy and what did he do

                                          Shou

                                            ^some south America pro who match fixed
                                            Got banned for 2 years then makes a Reddit post wanting u to pity him so he cud maybe get back in

                                            주 롄양

                                              i really like what tinkerlord said tho

                                              RIP

                                                he might deserve some sympathy, but not a second chance.

                                                Palmen aus Plastik

                                                  if smash gets unbanned, they should unban ddz too.

                                                  ETd

                                                    Personally i feel like he should, but as long as the CSGO guys who threw stay banned (ex-iBuyPower), it would be completely unfair if these guys get unbanned.

                                                    Actually, nvm. Professional athletes who matchfix can be criminally charged. These guys are already getting off light as it is.

                                                    Dogwater

                                                      I agree. If Valve wants esports to be respected then they should keep him banned. Also, it disrespects the players and the games.

                                                      Riguma Borusu

                                                        From reddit:

                                                        I understand that man but febby didnt even have a house for a year and he didnt match fix. Iirc rave only ate eggs and didnt eat when they didnt win tournies and i didnt hear them cheat. Its just not acceptable behavior. Good luck though.

                                                        [Lk].Zano

                                                          Meh, who cares.

                                                          I rape 1 person because life is hard and i cant have a gf. Can i have i second chance?

                                                          This is a particularly retarded comparison though, so it needs to get more attention.

                                                          I can’t believe its not h...

                                                            Offtopic here, but what Does the matchfixing mean ? It helps on What kinda way, or What it Does in the game/match?

                                                            I tried searching but couldnt find a proper one for it

                                                            კომენტარი შეიცვალა
                                                            Shou

                                                              It's when u decide the outcome of the match for some monetary gain before the match even starts. Usually involves purposeful losing.