I think the farming score is the only one which can be made a somewhat reliable indicator of skill from there, the other values seem to depend almost exclusively on your kda and hero damage so basically your performance won't be thought as a good one as long as your team lost, although that just might be the intent.
it only loads little more then half of my total games even when using hmy dota buff link and ive been linked for at least 3 months..
Applaud the effort, i will critique a few things:
1- none of my winrates are accurate to dotabuff.
2- First graphs is last 20 games. I find that much more important that the second two graphs. lifetime stats in dota are rather meaningless.
3- I like the idea behind the skill rating classifications (fighting, awareness etc) but I end up not being able to take them seriously. stats such as awareness are clearly just being taken from deaths or k/d etc. When you get stomped, it isn't necessarily because you aren't aware of the enemy teams movements, sometimes you just get gang stomped. More importantly as your enemy team snowballs, that score is going to continue to plummet, built it really has no reflection on awareness.
4- highly biased towards stackers (but then again so is win rate).
^because the dota API only stores a certain number of matches i think.
Dotabuff keeps the records longer, but if you make an account, keep it hidden, play 500 games, and then share your history, dotabuff will only be able to record the last 200 games or something.
Ahh ok :) Thx!
If i understand it, then all games played now will be recorded 100% for the "new" Page ? Only the initial Match fetching wasnt 100%
Obviously, all ratings are based off the match stats because they have no other info. Also, you can get good rating when loosing as long as you have good stats. For example, one game our team has better ratings (myself the best), but we lost due to fucking around too much.
http://mydotaskill.com/pokazmecz2.php?id=404803732
Overall, I think it provides not the "true skill" rating (since it depends on stats and varies so much) but rather your measurable match performance. I see it as a bit more useful variation of KDA.
კომენტარის დასაწერად გაიარეთ ავტორიზაცია.
Saw just today: http://mydotaskill.com
It is now calculating your "skill" across different measures (fighting, farming, awareness, pushing, teamplay). The numbers do not seem to be very stable for my matches. Also, it has a new match "balance" rating. My last 2 matches are "mediocre", next 3 are "nightmare".
What do you think? Can it be useful now that we have an official MMR?